Search for: All records

A central question for teachers is how to engage students in active reasoning while still aiming for substantial content goals. Asking students to generate and evaluate imagistic models can support both content learning and scientific thinking goals. Recent research indicates that imagery is a central component of scientific modeling (Schwartz and Heiser 2009). When discussing scientific models, teachers and students often lean heavily on words alone and overlook how modeling uses mental pictures and “mental movies.” Metaphorically, modeling processes can be thought of as occurring on a “sketch pad or video screen” of mental imagery in the student’s head. The set of strategies described here are intended to help teachers promote the kind of imagery that is used in scientific models. 

Abstract: This study investigates strategies teachers use to support mental imagery during modelbased science class discussions. A microanalysis of videos of classroom discussions was conducted in order to (1) identify and describe teaching strategies for supporting imagery; and (2) identify evidence that the students were engaging in the use of imagery as they constructed models and reasoned about competing models. This study starts from prior work on experts’ use of imagery, as well as from prior analyses of imagistic characteristics of concrete exemplars used successfully in a curriculum. Sixteen teacher support strategies for imagery are identified, along with thirteen student imagery process indicators. As the list of descriptors stabilizes, we are also identifying larger categories of descriptors—that is, structured categories of imagistic practices and categories of support. We present examples from a case study based on a transcript of a middle school discussion that served as one of the sources for our new organized set of imagery descriptors.